Xtreamer Ultra vs Boxee Box: media player showdownIn the world of pre-built, media streaming HTPC replacements, there’s really only one mainstream stand-out product, the D-link Boxee Box. Today, we put the Boxee Box up against its newest competitor, the Xtreamer Ultra which goes on sale early next week. The spec showdown awaits.

Let’s begin with processing power
After ditching Tegra2 in favor of Intel’s Atom processor, the Boxee Box finally decided on the Intel CE4110 system-on-a-chip platform consisting of a 1.2 GHz Intel Atom CPU. Xtreamer Ultra on the other hand went with a dual-core 1.8 GHz Intel Atom D525.

It’s all about the graphics
Since the Boxee Box uses the Intel CE4110 system-on-a-chip platform, it uses a PowerVR SGX535 integrated graphics processor which provides HDMI 1.3 output. Xtreamer Ultra ups the ante with the next-generation nVidia ION2, a GT218 40nm based GPU with 512MB of DDR3 memory.

What about memory and storage?
Having a powerful CPU and GPU are essential, but RAM is key when it comes to a smooth interface. The Boxee Box offers 1GB of RAM and 1GB of NAND Flash memory. The Xtreamer Ultra is a different beast, allowing up to 4GB of DDR3 memory to be installed and a 2.5” HDD bay for your choice of a SSD or laptop-sized hard drive.

Xtreamer Ultra vs Boxee Box: media player showdown

Connectivity is key
The Boxee Box offers a HDMI 1.3 output, optical audio (S/PDIF), RCA analog stereo, two USB ports, SD slot and 100Base-T ethernet. Xteramer Ultra features an HDMI 1.3a port, DVI, VGA, 1000Base-T ethernet, six USB ports, optical audio (S/PDIF), eSATA and mic input.

Software and add-ons
As the name implies, the Boxee Box is all about Boxee. The unit comes with a two-sided remote (keyboard on one side, navigation on the other). Xtreamer Ultra is a HTPC at heart, bundled with a MCE certified remote and capable of running Windows 7, Boxee, XBMC or Linux.

Wrapping it all up – Verdict
Overall the Boxee Box is a great solution if you love the Boxee interface. The Xtreamer on the other hand, is a much more powerful product capable of running several operating sytems, including Boxee. At its core, Xtreamer Ultra is a PC in a small form factor and if you were to run Windows 7, you wouldn’t be confined to the Boxee app library. At the end of the day, until we have a review unit on hand to compare to our Boxee Box, we can’t determine a winner.  So for now, we’ll let you decide a champion.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_HAXGYMKHRSU43C7DOT6Q2AYPSQ Wayne

    My Boxee Box is now a box after getting the black screen, updating to latest firmware made no difference and support from D-Link has been disappointing.
    When The Boxee worked it was great however the box would often freeze up, the remote is useless in the dark, reloading all the artwork is a pain and the interface needs work. And Boxee lose the sunken ship “box” look and give us a Gigabyte connection Was a big fan of the box but not any more. Especially as its now a brick and D-Link drag the chain big time on getting back with a solution. I will be buying the Ultra.

    • bensillis

      Sorry to hear that Wayne! Might I tempt you with an Ion 2 HTPC? they're really very good.

  • http://www.sitereviewboard.com/ Elton Sites

    Wow. nice competition there. But I think bot of the two are really cool stuff. But I need to do some further research on both devices to see which is better.

  • Eran83

    I guess i will wait patiently to the Xtreamer Ultra , it looks Fantastic .

  • TheNash

    This is a good article. It shows and compares the difference between the two pretty well. What is also does is show that these two are just too different to have a fair comparison.

    The Boxee Box is a dedicated device which runs the Boxee software. The Xtreamer Ultra is a mini PC, and like any computer with a decent GPU it can install Boxee… and anything else you want.

    I think a more fair comparison would have been to actually install Boxee on the Xtreamer then see which box handles it best (including pitting the remotes against each other). This way they are relatively on the same level.

    Having said that, I do appreciate knowing that at more or less the same price, the Xtreamer is capable of so much more than the Boxee box

    • TheNash

      In fact, I think the Xtreamer Prodigy will make for a more balanced comparison. It's also a dedicated media streamer so I look forward to seeing how it fares against the Boxee Box

  • http://twitter.com/hos_jonson Jonson

    i pre-ordered the Ultra because after 3 Months with Boxee Box from Dlink, which i buy for 229 €, i got nothing. Boxee promise updates and you have to wait 6 months for fixing some annoying bugs which render the Box useless. The crappy Apps crashes the Box 5 times a day. AC3 DD Audio dont work over SPDIF on most receivers. Everything is slow and laggy. The Browser is useless. The Database scanning is horrible. In the forum you got only promises or the great advise to check your network. It was intended good but the Soft- and Hardware is buggy and underpowered. The Mediaplayer from my Samsung TV is more capable then this Dlink Boxee Device. xtreamer ultra is the bang for the bug.

Hot chat, right here!


Our most commented stories right now...