Orange San Francisco review Orange San Francisco review

ratingratingratingratingrating
We love
Hi-res display, slim body, the price
We hate
Default UI is clunky, rubbish camera
Verdict
An absolute bargain that puts other budget Android rivals to shame
Launch Price
£99

Orange San Francisco review

The Orange San Francisco is one of the cheapest Android phones on the market. Android may be the seen as the biggest rival to Apple’s iPhone, but phones like this prove it’s a different kettle of piranhas altogether. An ancient battered first-gen iPhone will fetch more than a hundred quid on eBay, but the Orange San Francisco costs just a ton new. How can it possibly be any good? Find out in our Orange San Francisco review.

Like finding a tenner down the back of the sofa, the Orange San Francisco is a wonderful surprise that your wallet will thoroughly approve of. For the money you can snap one up for, a hundred pounds on a pre-pay deal, not only is there no better Android phone, there’s no better smartphone, full stop.

We’ll get onto the Orange San Francisco’s lame duck elements later and, gushing praise aside, there are a few, but prepare for a light-speed tirade of love as we look at what makes this phone special.

Serene screen

The AMOLED screen is phenomenal for the price you pay

Top of the list is the Orange San Francisco’s capacitive screen. The only Android that’s been widely available at a similar rock-bottom price to use a capacitive screen is the T-Mobile Pulse, which T-Mobile doesn’t even stock directly any more. The rest? They use resistive screens – perfect for use with a stylus, but with a finger navigation feels stodgy and slow. The San Francisco’s touchscreen isn’t as super-responsive as an HTC Desire running Android 2.2, but it’s lightyears ahead of its direct rivals.

Wait, it doesn’t just end there though. The Orange San Francisco also uses an AMOLED display, which we’ve never seen in a phone this cheap. AMOLED displays don’t use a backlight, letting them reproduce near-perfect black levels – backlit LCDs’ black areas always have some degree of luminescence, making them look a little blue or grey. The screen’s viewing angle are ridiculously good for a budget phone too, with almost no visibility deterioration whatsoever.

Check out our Best Android phone Top 5 now

Next up is the phone’s resolution. The Orange San Francisco uses a 480×800 pixel display. Packing 384,000 pixels into a 3.5-inch display gives this phone a brilliantly sharp image. With plenty of pixels and rockin’ AMOLED tech on-board, the San Francisco’s display can feasibly be compared to the screen of the original HTC Desire and Samsung Galaxy S, phone which cost around four times the price at launch, without having to bow its head in shame.

How has Orange managed to reproduce such high-end features at such a low price? Not a clue, but we’re impressed. Some props go to ZTE, the company that originally manufactured the device before it was given the Orange branding stamp.

Android 2.1

The Frisco sport a custom Android 2.1 skin

The Orange San Francisco runs Android 2.1. With Android 2.2 already here and Android 3.0 likely due for release within the next few months, it’s not bang up-to-date, but it’s not bad. Android 2.1 offers swish features like live wallpapers (animated backdrops for your homescreens) and, most importantly, it’s compatible with almost every major app currently available on the Android Market, Flash 10.1 plugin aside.

The only thing holding it back is its 600MHz processor. To get a kick into the 1GHz big leagues, you’d have to spend three times the price of the Orange San Francisco, but with a 600MHz clock speed some high-end apps may chug occasionally, and there will be some lag as you navigate around menus.

This lag gets annoying if you make do with Orange’s default UI, which encompasses five home screens and a static icon dock down at the bottom of the screen. Like all the worst custom UIs, it’s slow and cumbersome, but the Orange San Francisco seems to admit this.

What we love just as much as the phone’s great screen is that it’s humble. It comes with the naff UI in place as standard, but admits its own failures by adding the Homescreen Selector app. Here you can switch to the pre-installed Launcher alternative, which is free of Orange branding, or any others you’ve found on the Android Market. We switched to Launcher Pro, available for free from the Market (with some extra features costing a premium) and the Orange San Francisco slipped into the fast lane, with any lag annoyance wiped out.

Spend the time on a tweak or two, and the Orange San Francisco can better phones that’ll cost you much more. The HTC Wildfire has an inferior screen and will cost you at least £50 more. The Sony Ericsson Xperia X10 Mini offers a great UI and is tiny, but costs double the amount and runs the aged Android 1.6. If you want a cheapie Android phone on a pre-pay deal, this is the one to go for. As long as you can get on with following rotten eggs hidden under the carpet…

The cut corners

The Orange San Francisco’s 3.2-megapixel camera is awful. The autofocus is so slow that you could be forgiven for thinking you’d set it up for a 3-second delay. Even with the hands of a surgeon – and not one of those jittery alcoholic ones you see on TV either – your photos will often come out as a blurry, distorted mess. Yuck.

The AMOLED screen falls into a known trap of the screen tech, with slightly oversaturated colours. But even if that was to bother you, the built-in video skills aren’t good enough to highlight them too clearly. No DivX and XviD support means the majority of vids you’ve downloaded from the net will refuse to play. It’s a cut corner we could have predicted before even seeing the phone, but it’s a shame.

Let's just say the HTC Legend is a few leagues above when it comes to looks

Then there’s the styling. The Orange San Francisco is slim, petite given its 3.5-inch screen, and commendably solid. But parts of it don’t half look tacky. The cheap-looking silver strips down the side? The horrible camera lens housing? My, they’d get rotten veg thrown at them if they ever graced a catwalk. And that awful “San Francisco” font on the phone’s fascia? Darling, don’t even mention it – it’s hideous, simply hideous.

And yet, while these shortcomings became evident fairly soon after getting our hands on the Orange San Francisco, we’d urge you to forget them. If you’re watching your wallet, this is the best Android phone you could ask for, and it’s not that far off phones that would cost you £400 or so, SIM-free. As David Dickinson would say, it’s a bit of a bobby dazzler.

The Orange San Francisco has made our Best Android phone: Budget Top 5, which is why we’ve given it our Recommended rosette. Check out more Top 5s here and find out more about how they work with our Top 5 guarantee.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Patrick-Johnson/1315346778 Patrick Johnson

    Just got rid of mine as the screen was a nightmare to use.
    The screen did look better than the screen colours on the HTC Desire.

    Now got a secondhand palm pre for £145 from cex
    Miles better mobile

  • http://twitter.com/squidlaser laosquid

    It's a great phone. The screen can hardly be described as a nightmare to use. It is very responsive and like the review says, no stylus is required. An alpha release of Froyo 2.2 is up and running on it which has sped up the smoothness of the UI. All the Orange junk can easily be removed or hidden.

    For the price it cannot be beaten, and it doesn't actually look that tacky as stated in the review.

    • bensillis

      Hey laoqsuid, glad you're liking it. have you got video or instructions for the Froyo build? If you could send them to editor@electricpig.co.uk that'd be great.
      Cheers!
      Ben

  • Mace

    For what it is worth, I bought one of these off the back of this review to play about with.

    I unlocked it from Orange, rooted it for the princely sum of £1.99 and put a FroYo ROM on it and it works very very well, much better than when Eclair was on it.

    I can supply you instructions (and other 'things') and some pics if you wish?

    I will also be faffing with the VM heap soon to see if that improves things further.

    Smart phone bargain of the year for sure…. and probably next year too!

    • Mace

      oh…. and the 'Christmas gift box' it came with was an added bonus too! (watch, mini-playing cards, mini-rubix cube and a phone sock) :)

    • bensillis

      Ooo yes please Mace – if you send us photos and instructions we'll send you a mug and get you into the Electricpig VIPs group! Does it cope well with Flash?

      • Mace

        you have mail

  • http://twitter.com/stellaras1 steliOS

    Sucks,
    It has 1.35 SAR

  • David

    I have had a very bad experience with this phone on two levels.
    Firstly I have had four replacements now. With each phone experiencing the same problem, with the operations of the phone gradually getting slower and slower. I eventually had a member of Orange call staff admit that sometimes they get a batch of poor phones.
    Secondly I have found Orange's customer care to be appalling.
    - Call staff giving false names and extension numbers.
    - Call staff promising to call back but never doing so.
    - Hours spent having to call the support centre being passed between departments.
    - Being treated like I was being difficult in expecting to have a phone that worked.
    - The response from Orange is that they will keep sending me replacements until either the problems disappear (read: “disappears for long enough that I am no longer covered by a warranty”).
    Clearly some people have been lucky with this phone given the good reviews. However after this experience I can only question my decision to buy the phone and mostly buying from Orange.

    • bensillis

      Sorry to hear about the poor customer service, but are you sure this isn't general smartphone lag? Try installing LauncherPro and see if that speeds up your phone – also, while I don't usually recommend task killers, if it's kept happening it could be because you're always downloading a badly coded app each time – have a check in Settings to see if anything's gobbling up power.

  • Jack

    it’s compatible with almost every major app currently available on the Android Market.

    When I went to the Android Market It said my San Francisco was NOT an android and wouldn’t let me download. So this San Francisco is headed for ebay sharpish before other mugs discover this!!!

    • Anonymous

      Whoa – that’s not right. What was the wording of the error message?

  • grr at my phone

    HATE, HATE, HATE THIS PHONE!!! this phone is by far the worst phone i have ever had, its making me insane, it keeps freezing and my apps are painfully slow, but the worst thing of all is it takes forever to text, i got this phone because i wanted a contract and my old phone was slowing down after 2 years of use, but im gonna go back to my old phone as even that is faster and its nearlly dead. if you have to get a new phone i recommend the tocco light, its not slow like this and its very reliable and looks good.

    • Anonymous

      Sorry to hear that. Have you considered a custom ROM, or a different on-screen keyboard from the Android Market?

Hot chat, right here!


Our most commented stories right now...